We had a few good things last night and only one wine that was slightly disappointing.
Riesling Kabinett Urziger Wurzgarten 2004, Dr. Loosen
A ripe nose of exotic fruit with hints of spice. The palate has plenty of fruit too, and is quite sweet, but really lacking the acidity to make it balanced. It is a nice drink, but by no means a fine wine.
Chassagne-Montrachet 2004, Ramonet
A very refined nose of creamy minerality, lemon fruit and a surprising level of new oak. Even though it is quite oaky it is harmonious. The palate had great balance of fruit, acidity and oak. The finish has a pleasingly savoury character. For a village-level wine this is very good indeed.
Pommard Premier Cru Fremiers 2002, de Courcel
The nose is very ripe with plenty of red fruit, it smells really quite complex and earthy. The palate has very good fruit and a vigorous level of tannin. At the moment the tannins stand out a bit, but this is clearly balanced enough to age well. Going through a bit of an awkward stage at the moment, but a really serious wine.
Hermitage la Chapelle 1996, Paul Jaboulet-Aine
A very beautiful nose of that has fruit and a powerful earth character. It is clearly a very complex wine and quite manly too. Initially the palate seemed a touch angular, but on a second taste this seemed less bothersome and more balanced. It has great fruit on the palate, a high but balanced level of acidity and a real earthy power to it. Drinking remarkably well now, but it will keep. Very impressive.
Hermitage la Chapelle 1995, Paul Jaboulet-Aine
If the 1996 was manly the nose of this was positively heroic. Extremely ripe fruit, almost Porty, with soft earth and pepper. The palate was a monster of a mouthful, with very ripe tannins, plenty of fruit and real style. This is clearly a great wine, and very enjoyable at the moment. I'll be keeping mine for a bit longer, though.
Côtes-du-Rhône 2001, Château Fonsalette
The nose is very medicinal, with herbs and warm spice. For a Côtes-du-Rhône this is really quite complex. The palate is a bit dry and tannic, but seems to have some reasonably elegant fruit. Not bad, but perhaps a bit expensive.
Pinot Gris Grand Cru Altenberg Selection des Grains Nobles 2002, Domaine Weinbach
This smells very strongly of botrytis, with little else to discern there. The palate is very botrytic, too, and really rather sweet. However, there is no vineyard character and precious little Pinot Gris character. Where is the complexity? Where is the style? Where is the refinement? It is just a big glass of botrytis.